Gramercy Tavern'S Goodfellow Recipe – a delicious recipe with Chill an old-fashioned glass and rinse with pear liqueur, discarding any left in the bottom., Fill a cocktail shaker with ice and add Scotch, sherry, walnut liqueur, and bitters. Stir for until very cold, about 15 seconds, then strain into pear-rinsed glass., Curl orange twist over the drink to express oils, rub it zest-side down around the rim of the glass, and then discard twist and serve cocktail.. Easy to follow and perfect for any occasion.