Chicago Stuffed Pizza – a delicious recipe with Hot Tap Water, Active Dry Yeast, Sugar, All-purpose, Kosher Salt, Sugar. Easy to follow and perfect for any occasion.
-
1
For the dough:
-
2
In a measuring cup, combine 3/4 cups of hot tap water, yeast and 3/4 teaspoon of sugar.
-
3
Set aside to allow yeast to proof.
-
4
Youll see it get all foamy in about 5 minutes.
-
5
While your yeast is proofing, prepare the rest of the dough.
-
6
In the bowl of your stand mixer, combine the flour, salt, 3/4 teaspoons sugar and garlic powder.
-
7
Mix together with a fork to distribute the ingredients.
-
8
Add oil and combine the ingredients using the dough hook.
-
9
Add water/yeast mixture.
-
10
Mix with dough hook for 1 minute on low (I used speed 1).
-
11
Stop to scrape down the sides and bottom of the bowl.
-
12
Mix on speed 2 for 30 seconds.
-
13
Add 1 tablespoon of warm water, then mix on speed 4 for 2 minutes.
-
14
Add additional water 1 tablespoon at a time if the dough is not pulling away from the side of the bowl.
-
15
DO NOT OVER MIX!
-
16
It takes less than 5 minutes total mixing time for this crust, and thats what gives it the wonderful biscuit texture!
-
17
Transfer dough to a glass or ceramic bowl and let it rise for 4 hours.
-
18
(I put it in the oven and leave the door open.
-
19
The light from the oven is enough heat for the rise!)
-
20
You can use the dough at this point (if youre in a hurry), but youll get a much better texture and taste if you refrigerate it.
-
21
Refrigerate the dough (covered with celephane wrap) for 24-48 hours.
-
22
When you are ready to make your pizza, remove dough from fridge and allow dough to come to room temperature (took about 2 hours for me).
-
23
Weigh the dough.
-
24
Separate approximately 1/3 of the dough for the top skin.
-
25
Youll use the rest for the bottom.
-
26
When you start to roll the dough, preheat your oven to 450 F. You want the oven really hot!
-
27
If your baked goods tend to burn on the bottom, put a stone in the oven during the preheating and then you can put your pizza pan right on top of the stone.
-
28
Roll out the larger dough ball.
-
29
You shouldnt need any flour on the surface as this dough has a high oil content and doesnt stick!
-
30
Roll the dough very thin.
-
31
You should have about a 15-16 inch circle.
-
32
Generously butter the bottom of your pizza pan, plus butter half way up the side of the pan.
-
33
Place your crust in the bottom of the pan and tuck it into the bottom edges, with the crust coming up the sides and hanging over the top.
-
34
It should drape over the edges at least 1 inch all the way around your pan.
-
35
For the sauce: (See the notes at the end about the ingredients).
-
36
In a large pot, combine the 6-in-1 tomatoes, sugar, salt, crushed garlic and pizza seasoning.
-
37
I like to use an immersion blender to break up any tomato chunks, but you can whisk it together by hand, if you want!
-
38
Dont cook this.
-
39
Just mix it up and set to the side!
-
40
Now, start assembling your pizza!
-
41
Remember, this is stuffed, so theres a reason for the order!
-
42
You already have your bottom crust in the pan.
-
43
Now, put in your toppings one layer at a time.
-
44
If you are using sausage, you want this in the bottom so that its closest to the heat.
-
45
Dont pre-cook the sausage!
-
46
Place the sausage followed by other meatspepperoni, Canadian bacon, etc.
-
47
Then, place veggies on top of that.
-
48
Follow the veggies with your cheese.
-
49
Yes, the cheese goes on top of all of this!
-
50
Dont short change the cheese!
-
51
Now that youve built the stuffed part, roll out the remaining dough (this is the 1/3 that you put off to the side).
-
52
You want to roll this out extremely thin.
-
53
It should be almost transparent.
-
54
Roll this out to be about 11 around.
-
55
Lay this top skin on top of the cheese and up so that it extends about 1 all the way around your pizza pan.
-
56
Pinch the two doughs (your bottom crust and top skin) all the way around the pan (around the top edge) to seal the crust.
-
57
Using your finger, pull open about 8 holes in the top skin.
-
58
No need to be fancy!
-
59
I just use my finger and pull open some holes.
-
60
This will release the steam and keep the top from bubbling.
-
61
Double check the crust to make sure that its still sealed and that you didnt pull it apart when you were poking holes!
-
62
Pour 2 large ladles of sauce on top of the crust and swirl it around to cover the crust.
-
63
I know it sounds strange, but this kind of seals those top holes so that the sauce doesnt run down into the pizza.
-
64
After youve swirled, pour 2 more ladles of sauce on top to give it a nice top layer of sauce.
-
65
Use a sharp knife and trim the excess crust at the top outer edge of the pan.
-
66
Place in a 450 F oven for 30 minutes.
-
67
If your oven heats from the bottom, use a stone under your pizza pan to keep it from burning on the bottom.
-
68
I usually check it at 25 minutes to make sure the top edges of crust are not over cooking.
-
69
If the top edges look like they are browning too fast, lay a piece of foil on top.
-
70
You want to bake until your crust is a golden brown.
-
71
Remove the pizza from the oven and place it onto a cookie cooling rack.
-
72
Let it sit for a minute or two and then cut into 6 or 8 slices and serve!
-
73
Toppings options are as follows (pick your own, but here are some suggestions).
-
74
Dont cook any of it in advance unless noted.
-
75
Options: sweet Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, pepperoni, ground beef, olives (black or green), diced onions, spinach, pineapple chunks, diced green peppers, or whatever sounds good to you!
-
76
Notes about the ingredients:
-
77
6-in-1 Tomatoes in Heavy Puree is the sauce I use.
-
78
It does not contain any citric acid at all and is pure sweet tomatoes.
-
79
Bottom line ...
-
80
These are the very best and you can tell that with one little taste right out of the can!
-
81
They are hard to find, though!
-
82
You can purchase the #10 (huge) cans at Costco Business Center (not the regular Costco stores).
-
83
Or, you can order them directly from Escalon.net.
-
84
Shipping is reasonable and actually comes out to less per can than most stores!
-
85
Penzy Spice Pizza Seasoning: A very good mixture and the Penzy spices are amazing!
-
86
Check online for a store near you that carries them, or you can order directly from them at Penzeys.com.
-
87
But, this pizza seasoning mix is the perfect blend.
-
88
Cheese: You can get away with 10-12 ounces of whole milk mozzarella.
-
89
I actually blend my cheese.
-
90
I use about 5 ounces of whole milk mozzarella, 4 ounces of provolone and 3 ounces of skim (or low fat) mozzarella.
-
91
I also grate it fresh as opposed to pre-grated (because they use preservatives in the pre-grated to keep it from sticking to itself, which keeps it from melting in a creamy consistancy).
-
92
This is the minimum amount of cheese to use.
-
93
Ive used up to a pound before.
-
94
It depends on how full your pizza is from the other ingredients.
-
95
The first pizza you take out from you pan will probably crack when you remove it (normally on the side).
-
96
Its because we try to be too careful when taking it out.
-
97
Dont worry.
-
98
Make this a few times and youll be a pro at getting it out of the pan!
-
99
I took the extra sauce and warmed it on top of the stove while the pizza was baking for anyone who wanted some extra sauce on their pizza.
-
100
Just a small ladle of warm sauce on top!
No nutrition data on file — estimate from the ingredient list.
* Estimated from ingredient keywords · ingredients matched · Values are approximate and per serving (÷ 4).
No additional tips available.
No specific allergen information. Please check the ingredient list for possible allergens.
How did you like this recipe?
Frequently Asked Questions
This recipe makes 4 servings. You can adjust the portion size directly on this page.
You need 17 ingredients. The key ingredients include: 3/4 cups Hot Tap Water, 2 teaspoons Active Dry Yeast, 3/4 teaspoons Sugar, 3- 1/2 cups All-purpose Flour, and more.
Yes, Chicago Stuffed Pizza falls under the General category and is a great choice for this type of meal.
Store leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3–4 days. Reheat gently before serving.